The film is a danish production by zentropa, with international coproducers in sweden, france, germany and italy. Melancholia prominently features music from the prelude to richard wagner s opera. Melancholia is certainly a different kind of movie, and not one that hollywood would ever produce. The scene in melancholia where kirsten dunst was in such a wash of despair that could barely even bathe herself was so powerful for me. I understood the film as a competing set of epistemological claimsthats to say, not only how do we know certain things, and what method do we used to know them, but also what we do with this knowledge once we. Later, presumably in a tv documentary, he saw that saturn is the planet for melancholia, and, searching the internet, he suddenly came across a web page about cosmic collisions. The doctor may refer the person to a psychiatrist for a more indepth assessment. Melancholia definition of melancholia by merriamwebster.
Evan puschak, also known as the nerdwriter, digs into how the danish director represents this mental disorder in the films protagonist, justine kirsten dunst, by using cinematic. People with melancholic depression often feel extreme despair and guilt. The movie is far more compelling when its documenting depression in its first half than almost celebrating it in its second. In the second half of the movie justines fatalism will prove a. Acknowledgmentsthe author is grateful for comments to the manuscript provided by kerrie eyers. The controversial collection is made up of antichrist, melancholia, and the freshly squeezed nymphomaniac. In the dsm5, melancholia is a specifier for mdd, so a person would be diagnosed as having major depressive. In his new film melancholia, depression is like nothing so much as an alien planet hurtling toward earth on an apocalyptic, extinctionlevel trajectory. The wild symbolism and frank, disturbed erotica of antichrist, melancholia and nymphomaniac goes under the microscope. The treatment of depression, including melancholic depression, may involve antidepressants or. I agree that melancholia is not about depression understood in merely human terms, but i found it a good deal less light and comedic than you did. Another film that captures depression greatly is antonionis red desert, in which the state of the mind of the protagonist is accompanied by bleak industrial landscapes. The most common misconception about melancholia is that its a story about the end of the world. Melancholic depression is a form of major depressive disorder mdd that is characterized by a profound presentation of severe depression.
They may struggle to feel any happiness, even when good things happen in. Despite claires best efforts, the wedding is a fiasco, with family tensions mounting and relationships fraying. Distasteful as he may be in many ways, it is hard not to be moved by his stunning visual representation of depression. The experience of it is more like viewing and inhabiting a piece of art, than merely watching a movie. Kirsten dunst representing depression and not being bothered by the upcoming end of the world. Descriptions of what we now call melancholia or depression can be found in many ancient documents including the old testament, the book of job, and homers iliad, but there is virtually 1 the text of this ebook was prepared in 2002 for a presentation in mexico city. The second part of the movie takes place some time later. Melancholia remains wellfounded in its portrayal of depression and the weakness and the destruction of will that it brings upon an individual. Melancholia is a film that washes over you and through you and leaves you deeply moved and thrilled.
The movie is about the nature of depression and how 2 sisters go through it. In this beautiful movie about the end of the world, justine and michael are celebrating their marriage at a sumptuous party in the home of her sister claire, and brotherinlaw john. Melancholia resonated with all the pain and depression ive ever felt throughout my life. This article was supported by a grant from the national health and medical research council nhmrc 1037196. With this form of depression, there is a complete loss of pleasure in all or almost everything. I love the opening overture of impressionistic sights played to. Usually something insignificant, but can be something big and you just dont realize it. Justines depression has worsened, and shes come to live with her sister, claire charlotte gainsbourg. Film is an art form in which time and space are its main sources of expression, but what happens when these concepts are distorted through the lens of depression. Meanwhile, a planet called melancholia is in this beautiful movie. Evan puschak, also known as the nerdwriter, digs into how the danish director represents this mental disorder in the films protagonist, justine kirsten dunst, by using cinematic techniques to. Described as a beautiful movie about the end of the world, melancholia tells the story pf two sisters kirsten.
The movie is divided into two parts, the first about justines wedding, the second about the upcoming flyby of the rogue planet melancholia thats drifting through. It mainly focuses on the relationship between the two sisters justine and claire, played by kirsten dunst and charlotte gainsbourg. A movie where the protagonist is battling with depression and theres a giant blue planet hurtling towards the earth called. Kirsten dunst justine accepts her melancholia by the time a planet that was hiding behind the sun threatens to collide the earth, while other sister charlotte gainsbourg clair is afraid to face the reality and her own personal emotions. Melancholia is a hauntingly beautiful meditation on depression that is as likely to exasperate as many people as it moves. It is a statement movie, a statement that indicts our culture as being the ones that are missing the enormous heft and weight bearing down on the world today.
Treatment involves antidepressants, electroconvulsive therapy, or other empirically supported treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapy and. A woman dressed as a bride runs through a forest whose branches seem to grab at her in a disney nightmare. As someone battling with depression, i feel this movie and silver linnings playbook have done the best a conveying what it is like to cope with the illness. Melancholia is a word more often associated with hippocratic humors and romantic poets than modern neurobiology.
Antidepressant treatment of melancholia in late life. Melancholia strikes me as a more focused and harrowing portrait of clinical depression, a glowing, blackbile. Melancholic depression is often considered to be a biologically based and particularly severe form of depression. Melancholia is a commentary on the cultural assumptions and opinions of depressives. A rogue planet, melancholia, is seemingly on a collision course with earth, though claires husband kiefer sutherland asserts that it will be a near miss. I did not click on the link, because it will probably make the case for it being a rising allegory for depression, which is a fact that everyone who ever saw the film got. As the title suggests, melancholia is about the struggling relationship between sisters as one of them has severe depressi.
The two main protagonists, justine and claire, highlight two different manifestations of depression. Kirsten dunst is fantastic in the first half, and much more muted in the second. The movie melancholia a polemic on depression taylor. Ironically, while the ensuing oblivion brings on a condition of depressive, melancholia, justines sister, claire charlotte gainsbourg, struggles to. Listing a study does not mean it has been evaluated by the u. Hauntingly accurate portrayals of severe mental illness at. The first step to getting a diagnosis of depression, including melancholic depression, is to see a doctor or mental health professional. The arrival of melancholia the planet, that is reverses the traditional moral of that fable. Triers direction is awe inspiring and ambitious without feeling pretentious. Charlotte gainsbourg representing anxiety and freaking out because of. Justine kirsten dunst and michael alexander skarsgard celebrate their marriage at a. Antidepressant treatment of melancholia in late life the safety and scientific validity of this study is the responsibility of the study sponsor and investigators. She floats in a pond, holding flowers, like ophelia. Another woman makes her way with a child over marshy grass that sucks.
163 79 1412 303 1627 1444 150 1374 367 1460 1297 827 289 515 958 291 1050 959 875 1615 1458 1657 1422 13 716 1449 200 385 637 310 337 787